Stay ahead of the curve as a political insider with deep policy analysis, daily briefings and policy-shaping tools.
Request a Demo- Program for thousands of struggling students caves in three years.
- Tension built between program leader and state schools chief.
- Audit targets consultant fees and spotty oversight.
Amid Cooper-Carver’s success, Peters said she heard complaints from some school leaders about their districts’ assigned specialists. Alexander, who mainly focused on Randolph County schools, heard officials at the Richmond County School Systems were talking about dropping the office entirely.
Before long, the two largest school districts under the program – Richmond County and Savannah-Chatham County – stopped working with specialists. Representatives from those districts declined or could not be reached for interview requests to discuss why.
Discontent from some districts was also relayed to Cecily Harsch-Kinnane, the policy and outreach coordinator for the advocacy group Public Education Matters Georgia. Like many local school advocates, she traced the turnaround office’s downfall partly to how it was set up.
“What it had going was promising,” said Harsch-Kinnane, who formerly served on the Atlanta Board of Education. “But it was always a turf war of sorts.”
The turnaround program emerged after a failed push in 2015 by lawmakers backed by then-Gov. Nathan Deal to create a different program called the Opportunity School District, which could assume control of failing public schools in Georgia. School leaders, teachers, parents and voters across the state squashed that program almost as soon as it reared its head, bashing it as an unwanted power grab by the state to take over local schools. Mistrust lingered in the education community when the Chief Turnaround Office was pitched as a compromise idea in 2017.
“This was a difficult issue to take on back then,” said former Rep. Kevin Tanner, who sponsored a bill to create the turnaround office. “The educational community was very skeptical.”
Keeping the turnaround office separate from Woods’ larger agency was done partly to avoid another clash over state takeover, said Tanner, who is now the county manager for Forsyth County. The approach won support from the legislature’s majority Republican members and powerful Democratic leaders such as 2018 gubernatorial candidate Stacey Abrams. But seven local school advocates interviewed for this story all agreed the split between Thomas’ turnaround program and Woods’ state agency created friction from the start, particularly since the state already had a division under Woods that worked with struggling schools.
“It was creating a duplicative department,” said Lisa Morgan, president of the Georgia Association of Educators. “Politics reigned supreme rather than thinking what’s best for our students and educators.”
Support for the turnaround program waned after Gov. Brian Kemp took office in 2019, shortly before Woods lobbied lawmakers to bring the quasi-independent program under his direct watch. Kemp showed less interest in continuing the program than did his predecessor Deal, according to advocates. He also appointed several new state education board members who were not involved in the program’s creation.
Thomas, the turnaround chief, noticed collaboration with Woods tapering off after the program’s first six months, giving the impression that he and his staff were being iced out despite a mandate from the state legislature that the two offices work together, records show. Woods’ office also still controlled the purse strings for federal struggling-school funds, including disbursements of $3.6 million that went to 10 rural schools not working with the turnaround program. Thomas concluded in a January 2020 report that “decisions to not collaborate and to not prioritize funding for (turnaround) schools were wrong.”
A spokeswoman for the state education department said Woods did meet with Thomas “multiple times throughout his tenure,” though noted “several instances” in which Thomas requested meetings with “extremely short notice” or “was unwilling to meet” with some of Woods’ staff. The spokeswoman also disputed claims that the state withheld federal funding to schools under Thomas’ charge, saying many schools did receive funding while some “were not federally identified” to qualify.
“The arrangement presented challenges largely due to lack of alignment and oversight,” said the state agency’s communications director, Meghan Frick. “Having fiscal and legal responsibility for a program over which we did not have direct oversight or supervision put the agency in a difficult position.”
Meanwhile, some advocates wondered if the turnaround program was jogging in place. Meetings with an advisory group hinted at little progress as Thomas delivered what sounded like the same updates month after month, said John Zauner, executive director of the Georgia School Superintendents Association.
“There were certainly some red flags as time went on in the meetings,” Zauner said in a recent interview. “There wasn’t any moving the football down the field, if you will.”
Then came the audit of the turnaround program in late 2019.
NEXT
Part IV: Audit questions contractor pay
Header image: Left: Eric Thomas; right: Richard Woods (Credit: Georgia Department of Education)
What should Georgia do with its $16 billion surplus? ‘Fix the roads,’ voters say
Editor’s note: This is the second of a three-part series for which State Affairs spoke with voters across the state about their most pressing concerns this election season. Their answers were vastly varied and, in some cases, surprising. Read Part 1 here. First-time voter Miracle Jones plans to cast her vote for Donald Trump. Fitzgerald …
‘There’s a lot on the line’: Voters across Georgia weigh in
Editor’s note: This is the first of a three-part series looking at voter views and concerns. State Affairs spoke with voters across Georgia. Their responses were vastly varied and, in some cases, surprising. Read Part 2 here. Georgia voters are toting to the polls a mixed bag of views and concerns about the direction of …
Need a refresher on key state races this election? We’ve got you covered
Georgians are engrossed in the contentious presidential race between Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump. Keep in mind, though, all 236 members of Georgia’s House and Senate are up for reelection in November. Many are incumbents who’ll easily win a return to the Capitol in January. Yet there are some down-ballot races …
An early primer: 7 things you need to know before the Nov. 5 election
The 2024 general election is eight days away. Here’s what you need to know to vote in the Nov. 5 general election. 1. I plan to vote in person. Do I need identification? You’ll need a valid driver’s license, U.S. passport, military identification, tribal ID or state ID. If you don’t have any of those …